Categories
Epistemology Philosophy Philosophy of Science

Materialist science?

This is a reply I wrote in 2017 as part of an interesting discussion with a colleague concerning whether idealism, or anti-materialism, had any place in a naturalistic philosophy of science.

Even without going as far as scepticism surrounding causation or induction, there are plenty of problems if we consider the body of science to merely be a vast collection of perceptions. My main point of interest here – and one which I think has real relevance to data science – is the different between “knowledge” and “understanding”.

But I wouldn’t be too quick to write off Berkeley’s idealism (or anti-materialism, if you will).

Categories
Backgammon Epistemology Philosophy Philosophy of Science

The Data Deluge Makes the Scientific Method Obsolete

Do qualitative and quantitative changes in our capacity to gather and process (big) scientific data change the way we do science? Might they actually usurp the scientific method itself? In fact, is there anything more to the scientific method than just analysing data?

This is a discussion of an article that appeared in wired The End of Theory: The Data Deluge Makes the Scientific Method Obsolete.

To me the article seems to be a little speculative – and gives a sense of philosophical deja vu.

Categories
Backgammon Philosophy Philosophy of Science

Backgammon as a miniature natural system

This was written back in 2009. Some of the references are out of date, and the insights seem more commonplace now. I can’t tell if that’s because they’ve been borne out by time, or that they were obvious all along.

Backgammon is an ancient game, perhaps the oldest in the world.

Despite the fact that the inner workings of the game โ€“ the rules of checker movement โ€“ are obviously of human invention, the obscurity of their providence and their sheer simplicity almost makes them akin to natural physical laws, applying themselves to the minimalistic universe of the backgammon board.

Like the physical world, too, backgammon might seem to us to behave as an intractable mixture of determinism and randomness. Reports of games very similar, but presumably genetically unrelated, to backgammon being played by native people in the New World by the first European explorers might suggest that backgammon-like games represent a natural class of game to emerge from the mathematics of probability and position.

Because the study of this world โ€“ the science of backgammon โ€“ may be pursued for both fun and (gambling) profit, it too has a long history. And curiously, this natural philosophy follows a similar path to investigations of the broader universe.