Categories
Books Nonfiction Reviews

Review: The Lies That Bind

By Kwame Anthony Appiah (2018)

This is wonderful, just so clear and wholesome in a discussion of a subject – identity – which can of course be pretty fraught.

It belongs to that rare class of writing where the language is so crisp and readable, you barely notice you’re being lead to some really philosophically interesting places. I particularly like his take on meritocracy, which is an idea that exercises me a lot. He does talk quite a lot about himself – but then he’s had such an interesting life and background, I hardly blame him.

Categories
Books Nonfiction Reviews

Reviews: Modern African History

The Scramble For Africa by Thomas Pakenham (1990) & The State of Africa by Martin Meredith (2005)

The Scramble For Africa. This is just fascinating – surely one of the strangest few decades in history. Other than the pretty horrific behaviour of the colonists – who, perhaps Brazza excepted, were tremendously low-rent graspers and cheats (as well as plain brutal) – what most strikes me is how shoestring the whole business was. Regions the size of France “claimed” by a few dozen troops, etc. I’ve actually read this before – but the weird format (it’s all chronological, rather than by area) meant I struggled to piece together the whole arc of regions like the Congo. So I only read the central Africa sections in sequence this time, about half the book.

Categories
Books Nonfiction Reviews

Review: Other Minds

By Peter Godfrey-Smith (2016)

This really is excellent! Learnt loads on this (pretty fascinating) subject (intelligence and cognition in octopuses and cuttlefish). To my surprise it also includes a short account of the theory of ageing – which I had a chapter of my PhD on. Usually you see the cracks when an author moves onto something you’re very familiar with, but I have to say he pretty much nails it. It actually sent me back to my thesis (for the first time in 8 years) to refresh myself on the background.

Genuine sense of affection and pathos for these wonderful animals. Was quite cut-up at the inevitable death of the short-lived intelligent giant cuttlefish.

Categories
Books Nonfiction Philosophy Reviews

Review: Feline Philosophy

By John Gray (2020)

So, this continues my frustrating relationship with John Gray, where I can appreciate he’s a good writer (crisp, clear, readable etc) but his basic positions seem โ€ฆ unfounded to me. And he doesn’t seem particularly interested in arguing for them, but just leans on the fact they’re unpopular to make them “unpalatable truths”, or something.

Categories
Books Ethics/Metaethics Nonfiction Philosophy Reviews

Review: Evil in Modern Thought

By Susan Neiman (2002)

If I described this as an serious academic work of philosophy arguing how the Problem of Evil (is suffering deserved?) did not disappear into theology in the 18th century – you might not think it’s a exactly a page-turner. But it’s gripping!

A brilliant explanation of Kantโ€™s intention, or an even more brilliant novelty. The tragedy of contingency, and the comedy of there being no limits to the number of things that can go wrong.

Categories
Books Lit Crit Nonfiction Reviews

Review: Provocations

By Camille Paglia (2018)

I completely failed the first time, so I tried again on holiday to get through Provocations by Camille Paglia.

My conclusion: that I am done with Camille Paglia. Her contrarian shtick may have been refreshing fifteen years ago but her act has been stolen by the intellectually vacuous and she’s keen to follow them

Categories
Books Nonfiction Politics Reviews

Review: How To Be A Liberal

By Ian Dunt (2020)

A real achievement. It’s ambitious – I started off thinking he’d bitten off a bit more than he could chew. It’s both very contemporary – up to the minute even – and a sweeping history of the liberal tradition.

Does a remarkable job considering this scope – even for well-known parts of the story or figures like John Stuart Mill, brings out wonderful details that (I at least) just wasn’t aware of – like he effectively co-wrote much of his work with his partner, then wife, Harriet Taylor, and was dedicated to the rights of women. Not to mention bringing in really interesting guys like Benjamin Constant, who I’d plain never heard of.

Categories
Books Humour Nonfiction Reviews

Review: Spanish Steps

By Tim Moore (2004)

I keep returning to Tim Moore, since in theory he’s right up my street, disappearing on ridiculous self-inflicted adventures which just so happen to go wrong in entirely foreseen ways. In this one he walks a donkey along the Santiago de Compostela.

It did have quite a few of the things that frustrate me, including the totally accidental I didn’t intend to turn this into a book because that’s my job wackiness, and his tendency to give up and get his wife to fly over and bail him out, which I swear happens in every book and completely deflates the sense that things are out of control.

Nevertheless, reliably funny, and being forced to get along with his fellow pilgrims stops him sinking into misanthropy which can be a problem in his other books.

Categories
Books Nonfiction Politics Reviews

Reviews: Anne Applebaum on Eastern Europe

Iron Curtain: The Crushing of Eastern Europe (2012) and Between East and West: Across the Borderlands of Europe (1994) by Anne Applebaum

Anne Applebaum’s recent book is so good, I’ve been working my way through her back catalogue.

Two books about the “borderlands” of Europe – Poland, Lithuania, Ukraine, Hungary, Belarus and Moldova – their crushing and Sovietization following 1944, and subsequent re-emergence in the 90s are excellent if you have an interest the region, its history, and the recent destablilisation.

Pure joy, and the best non-fiction book I’ve read this year

Categories
Books Lit Crit Nabokov Nonfiction Reviews The Feud

Review: The Feud

Vladimir Nabokov, Edmund Wilson and the end of a beautiful friendship by Alex Beam

An amusing, light-footed but increasingly partial and even sloppy account of the infamous disintegration of a long-standing literary friendship.

What’s important in a friendship? Does loyalty and tolerance in disagreement come first – or does principal, character and rapport count for more? For a quarter of a century, Vladimir Nabokov – already a well-respected Russian author in the European emigration, but virtually unknown in his adopted American home; and Edmund Wilson, the pre-eminent critic of his day, were vital friends.